Hobby Lobby – Crafting Religious Freedom

Posted on
Hobby Lobby defies HHS Mandate

As a group of crafty Catholic women, joining Pinterest was a no-brainer for many of the Catholic Sistas Ink Slingers. As an Art Major, former Catholic school art teacher, homeschool mother, and now homeschool Nana this was certainly true for me.  Therefore, this past Advent and Christmas season brought me to Hobby Lobby more times than I can count. They have always had my respect as a Christian- owned business that closes on Sundays  “the day most widely recognized as a day of rest, in order to allow our employees and customers more time for worship and family”. So what’s not to like?

ObamaCare Enters In

Conversely, Hobby Lobby  hardly seems like a name that would appear in the same sentence with the HHS Mandate – yet here we are. It appears that the insidious HHS Mandate has encroached even into the world of Christian, crafty, self-made entrepreneurs.  At first glance, ObamaCare appeared to be a virtuous idea to some, even as others struggled with the strangle hold it would have on every citizen in the nation. That topic alone would garner a several part series for another day. The portion of ObamaCare that is more easily isolated and agreed upon is the portentous HHS Mandate, which will force – as of January 1, 2013 – businesses, organizations, and institutions to provide contraception, sterilization, and abortion inducing drugs to all of their employees – free of charge.

What about Freedom of Religion?

“What about Freedom of Religion?” you might ask. According to Stuart Delery , Acting Assistant Attorney General, “Hobby Lobby is a for-profit, secular employer, and a secular entity by definition does not exercise religion”.  Therefore  “because Hobby Lobby is a secular employer, it is not entitled to the protections of the Free Exercise Clause or RFRA [the Religious Freedom Restoration Act]”.

Wait a minute! Don’t they realize that a corporation is made up of people? That those who spend their lives taking the risks it takes to create a business do so according to their religious beliefs and core values? Even at a corporate level, moral decisions are made every day – such as how to treat employees, customers, and vendors. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, “Economic activity, conducted according to its own proper methods, is to be exercised within the limits of the moral order, in keeping with social justice so as to correspond to God’s plan for man” 2426. Trying to divorce principles from the business world creates exactly the type of selfish capitalism against which we rail.

Freedom of Worship vs. Freedom of Religion

The reasoning put forth by the Obama Administration exemplifies the push for freedom of worship rather than freedom of religion that is stealthily being integrated into our culture these days. In this highly flawed rationale, every person has the right to worship in the way they desire but they should leave that philosophy at the church steps. Once one enters into day to day life, all religious bets are off, so to speak,  and we are to neutralize our belief system at the behest of the secular world. This way we don’t impose our values onto others and we don’t strain the sensibilities of those who do not believe as we do. But aren’t we all here to work toward heaven together? Shouldn’t we encourage godly thinking and morality for all? Yes, and that is why this situation is so pertinent to all of us!

The Church Stance

So is the Church really on board with the civil disobedience planned by the Bishops? Blessed John Paul II, in his Encyclical, Evangelium Vitae, stated, “in the case of an intrinsically unjust law, such as a law permitting abortion or euthanasia, it is therefore never licit to obey it”, or to “take part in a propaganda campaign in favour of such a law, or vote for it”. This ideal of following God first and civil authority second goes all the way back to the Bible where Acts 5:29 tells us, “ But Peter and the apostles answering, said: We ought to obey God, rather than men”. Preferably, as godly American citizens, we would do well to replicate the dedication of Saint Thomas More who, according to Pope Benedict XVII, “…followed his conscience, even at the cost of displeasing the sovereign whose ‘good servant’ he was, because he chose to serve God first.” After all, the very morality of our nation is at stake and we fight for justice for all of our brethren!

So What Does this all Mean?

Although Hobby Lobby is the only non-Catholic business of the 42 cases and over 110 plaintiffs being brought against this unconstitutional mandate, they are the largest and therefore have the most money to lose as far as potential fines go.  For Hobby Lobby, civil disobedience will mean up to $1.3 M in fines – per day! Having been denied an injunction by several judges, including Supreme Court Justice, Sonya Sotomayer (a Catholic) , they appear to be poised to risk just that. This is where we all come in as the people of God. If a Christian business is willing to face financial ruin for their moral principles shouldn’t we step up in solidarity? Shouldn’t we raise them up in prayer and in deed?

Plan of Action

Hobby Lobby defies HHS Mandate

I propose that we shop Hobby Lobby first, when it comes to the type of products that they carry. Further, I’d love to see them receive many votes of confidence in the form of emails and letters. Not to be forgotten, it behooves us to pray mightily for them and for all of the brave soldiers in this fight for Religious Freedom. The USCCB has given us a campaign in which to participate – Prayer for Life, Marriage, and Religious Freedom.

1) Eucharistic Adoration
2) Daily Family Rosary
3) Mass intentions for Life, Marriage, and Religious Freedom
4) Abstaining from meat and fasting every Friday
5) A second Fortnight for Freedom at the end of June and the beginning of July 2013 emphasizing Life, Marriage and Religious Freedom in light of the HHS Mandate.

Wrap Up

All in all, the most important consideration is that we are all in this together. This is not just another political issue that has valid, moral points on either side. Nor is it something to be easily dismissed because it’s not really relevant to us. No, this is a trail down a very slippery slope whose outcome will be affecting our lives very intimately in all the years to come. Don’t dismiss this issue out of hand! Instead join us as we pray, fast, and act on behalf of following the laws of the God of Life! May the Goliath of Big Government be subdued by the unified Davids to be found in those brave enough to defy the HHS Mandate, plus you and me!

Despite Sotomayor Ruling, Hobby Lobby Won’t Comply With Abortifacient Mandate 

Beckett Fund and the other plaintiffs

8 Replies to “Hobby Lobby – Crafting Religious Freedom”

  1. Thanks Birgita, for writing this. It is so good to know that there are still godly businesses out there who have the backbone to resist this mandate. Does anyone know anything about the status of big-box stores like Sam’s with respect to the mandate? Thanks for keeping us informed.

  2. I am a subscriber to Catholic Sistas and am overall very satisfied with the content I receive.

    I’m not trying to sound angry or unsympathetic but Hobby Lobby has absolutely no right to attempt getting out of this coverage. The Catholic Church and Hobby Lobby are two entirely different issues. The Catholic church and it’s “industries” being of a religious bend and Hobby Lobby being of a corporate bend.

    I think Catholics, as a group are just muddying the waters by backing this very different situation from ours

    This is not a slippery slope, it’s two entirely different mountains.

  3. Linda, thank you for sharing your thoughts. I’d love to hear your reasoning behind your statement, ‘Hobby Lobby has absolutely no right to attempt getting out of this coverage’.

    Although I’d agree that Hobby Lobby and the Catholic Church are different entities, one’s right don’t exclude the rights of the other. As citizens of the United States of America, we are all entitled to the right to the free exercise of our religious beliefs. Therefore, the Greens have just as much right to exercise their values as any other citizens. It also follows that one must not be a church to be entitled to the conscience exemption. Whether university, hospital, charity, or business – all Christians have the same rights that preclude the government from forcing them to act in a manner repugnant to them.

    It might be helpful for you to follow the provided link to familiarize yourself with all of the various types of businesses, institutions, and groups that are filing lawsuits opposing the HHS Mandate. Not all of them are Catholic and not all of them are dioceses. The right to religious freedom does not solely belong to churches, it belongs to each individual. http://www.becketfund.org/hhsinformationcentral/

  4. Funny I just had a conversation with my mom about this, she believe you just have to repent and tha is it, she is not a practicing catholic she practice yoga, but I want to send this article for her to read, is there anyway I could get it in spanish?….please

Comments are closed.